Intelligence Does Not Protect Us from Our Own Contradictions.

We tend to think that the more intelligent a person is, the better they reason and the fewer mistakes they make. Yet intellectual ability and the ability to recognise our own errors are not quite the same thing. Someone with strong analytical skills can use them to examine their beliefs, but also to construct increasingly sophisticated arguments to protect them. Intelligence can serve both to bring us closer to the truth and to justify what we need to keep believing.

This raises a paradox about human thought: perhaps the hardest people to convince are not always those who know the least, but those who have more intellectual resources to defend their positions. We can confuse the ability to argue with the ability to think critically. The first consists of finding reasons to support a conclusion; the second requires being willing to abandon it when the evidence contradicts it. Do we use our intelligence to discover when we are wrong, or to make sure we never have to admit it?