The Paradox of Knowing What We Want

We often assume that personal freedom consists in being able to pursue whatever we desire. But this assumes something rarely examined: that we already know what we want. Human preferences are not fixed properties waiting to be discovered. They develop through experience, social influence, available opportunities and the very choices we make. Sometimes we only discover that we wanted something after encountering it; at other times, we abandon desires we once considered essential. The person making a decision today is not necessarily the person who will live with its consequences tomorrow.

This introduces a deeper problem than choosing between alternatives: how can we know whether our present desires deserve to determine our future? If experience can transform the very preferences through which we evaluate our decisions, then the freedom to choose is also the freedom to become someone whose desires are different from those we have now. Are we choosing the life we want, or choosing the person we will eventually become?