Human beings do not learn only by observing what works. We also observe who appears successful and tend to imitate them. Evolutionary psychology has studied this mechanism as prestige-biased social learning: we attribute value to someone’s knowledge because they occupy a respected position within a group. The problem arises when we extend that trust to fields in which those individuals have no demonstrated expertise.
A person can accumulate authority in one field and eventually be listened to on entirely unrelated subjects. Their reputation then becomes a kind of intellectual currency, allowing them to influence others without having to demonstrate knowledge. How many of our own convictions actually come from understanding something, and how many come from trusting the person who said it?