The Uncertainty of Being Free

We usually associate freedom with the absence of external constraints. Yet there is another possibility: that our greatest limitations do not come from what prevents us from acting, but from the conditions that determine what we are capable of wanting, imagining and choosing. A person born into a particular historical period inherits a language, a culture, a set of values and an understanding of what constitutes a possible life. These influences operate long before conscious reflection begins. We may feel entirely free when making decisions while remaining unaware of the invisible boundaries within which those decisions become conceivable.

This creates a difficult philosophical problem. To question the limits of our freedom, we must first recognise limitations that our own minds may be incapable of identifying. Even our rebellion against inherited assumptions is expressed through concepts and possibilities inherited from somewhere else. If we cannot step entirely outside the conditions that shape our thinking, how can we ever know the true extent of our freedom?